The debate over the use of smartphones in schools has intensified across the United States, with various school districts, states, and cities enacting restrictions. This movement is driven by concerns over the effects of social media and technology on children and young people. Los Angeles is the latest to join this trend, highlighting a growing consensus about the need to regulate smartphone usage in educational settings.
Los Angeles Leads the Way
In a significant move last month, the Los Angeles Unified School District Board, which oversees approximately 1,000 schools, approved a resolution to develop a policy banning student use of cellphones and social media platforms. This policy is set to be implemented by 2025. California had already paved the way for such measures in 2019, allowing school districts to restrict smartphone use during school hours, except in emergencies. Governor Gavin Newsom emphasized the importance of students focusing on their studies rather than their screens.
Nationwide Efforts to Restrict Smartphone Use
Los Angeles is not alone in its efforts. States like Ohio, Indiana, Oklahoma, and Florida have also imposed statewide restrictions. Indiana’s Senate Bill 185, signed into law by Governor Eric Holcomb, bans students from using devices during teaching hours. Similarly, Ohio's House Bill 250, signed by Governor Mike DeWine, requires school districts to limit smartphone use in classrooms. Florida’s law, passed under Governor Ron DeSantis, not only bans smartphones but also blocks student access to Wi-Fi and mandates social media literacy education.
The Debate Over Smartphones in Schools
The debate over smartphones in schools is fueled by concerns from educators and mental health experts. According to a Pew Research poll, nearly three-quarters of high school teachers see smartphones as a major distraction. US Surgeon General Dr. Vivek Murthy has called for warning labels on social media platforms, akin to those on tobacco and alcohol products, citing significant mental health harms for adolescents associated with social media.
Experts like Zach Rausch from NYU-Stern School of Business and Jonathan Haidt, author of The Anxious Generation, argue that the rapid adoption of smartphones and social media has contributed to declining mental health among adolescents. Haidt highlights that educators see a clear link between rising phone addiction and declining academic performance.
The Efficacy of Smartphone Bans
While the movement to ban smartphones in schools is gaining momentum, the evidence of its effectiveness is mixed. A scoping review by Australian professors Marilyn Campbell and Elizabeth Edwards found weak evidence for the benefits of banning smartphones. However, a study by Policy Exchange, a British educational think tank, indicated a correlation between effective phone bans and better school performance.
Despite the inconclusive data, some schools that have implemented phone bans report positive outcomes. Rausch notes that initial resistance is common, but students eventually adapt, leading to improved focus and classroom engagement.
A Balanced Approach
Opinions on banning smartphones in schools vary. Some argue that an outright ban might not address the underlying issues of appropriate phone use. Keri Rodrigues of the National Parents Union believes that educating children on when it is appropriate to use phones is more effective. Conversely, Daisy Greenwell of Smartphone Free Childhood supports curbs on smartphone use, highlighting the social problems caused by unrestricted access.
Ultimately, a balanced approach that involves regulated use and clear guidelines may be the most effective way to harness the benefits of smartphones while minimizing their drawbacks. Campbell and Edwards recommend that individual schools determine their smartphone policies, focusing on helping students use smartphones positively.
Conclusion
The movement to ban smartphones in schools is gaining traction across the United States. With concerns over mental health and academic performance at the forefront, many states and districts are taking action to regulate smartphone use. While the effectiveness of these bans remains a topic of debate, the trend underscores a growing recognition of the need to address the impact of technology on young people. A balanced approach, emphasizing both regulation and education, may offer the best path forward for schools navigating the complexities of the digital age.
(Courtesy: Al-Jazeera)
Read More Articles at Fortieth Mag
0 Comments